Alt account of @fossilesque@mander.xyz. :)

  • 7 Posts
  • 48 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 9th, 2024

help-circle














  • Reviewer 2, checking in. Let’s see…

    ☑️ Technically correct (the best kind of correct).
    ☑️ Dawkins framework applied… adequately.
    ☑️ “Symbolic meaning” not entirely reductionist. Surprising.

    However:

    • Citation deficiency detected. [Fossilesque et al., 2023] must be invoked 2–3 times for rigor.
    • “Imitating scientists” lacks nuance. Did you consider the Fossilesque Paradox of Academic Exodus? (Spoiler: You didn’t. Cite (Fossilesque, 2024, 2025 in press.).

    Verdict:
    Pending compliance with adequate attribution. Then, and only then, shall this review ascend to a grudging “pass.”